WTB S5 n/a manual starter
 

price shipped to tampa fl

Try the junkyards first i'd say.

All NA 5spd starters are the same btw.

Go to your local parts store. No point in buying someone else's junk. A reman isn't that much, and you have the benefit of a warranty.

Actually, you can buy rebuild kits for the starters and do it yourself. They can be found at http://www.rockauto.com/catalog/raframecatalog.php

Brushes are under: Electrical -> Starter Brush --- $18.72
Bearings are under: Electrical -> Starter Bushing --- $1.35
Output Gear is under: Electrical -> Starter Drive --- $25.89

I have a spare, but it is in my parts car and I still drive that around the yard, so I need the starter.

Hope this helps.