Trans difference

WE3RX7 · 11-27-2014, 12:54 PM

Well you've been in the S1 trans more than I have but I've been looking at doing an NC2 MX-5 (late 2010+ production) 6spd. Its built by Mazda, not Aisin. Stronger steel/metal used, better synchros, shift rods, forks, etc. In theory it won't wear like the S1 RX8 trans will, causing the grinding and shift keys/detent pins to vacate their premises. I haven't really played with an R3 trans yet (S2) but it's probably fairly similar in improvements like the newer NC MX-5 ones are. Better 4th gear ratio too...

To answer the OP question, if starting from scratch with a custom build... and I had a choice of S1 or S2 RX-8 trans, I'd select the S2. But if I could go with ANY Mazda production trans in the recent years, it'd be the NC MX-5 6spd (mounts on the drivers side PPF as well as the RX-8 so may be fairly easy to mount). Also, more support in the racing world for MX-5.. the weaknesses the MX-5 trans has have aftermarket fixes for already.

I for one don't have many issues with my current S1 trans. It has been raced for the last 6 years pretty consistently and has over 90K miles on it. However, I've never been a gear slammer and take the right time between gear selections... also, I really believe the precision of the Exedy unsprung clutch system has helped tremendously with the RX8 trans. Is my trans perfect? No, but it's lasted WAY better then I thought it would...

More trans research for next year as I'll probably pull the engine/trans for updates at that time...

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Switch to Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Threaded Mode

11-27-2014, 12:54 PM	#5
WE3RX7 RCC Addict Join Date: Feb 2008 Location: VA Posts: 1,812 Rep Power: 19	Well you've been in the S1 trans more than I have but I've been looking at doing an NC2 MX-5 (late 2010+ production) 6spd. Its built by Mazda, not Aisin. Stronger steel/metal used, better synchros, shift rods, forks, etc. In theory it won't wear like the S1 RX8 trans will, causing the grinding and shift keys/detent pins to vacate their premises. I haven't really played with an R3 trans yet (S2) but it's probably fairly similar in improvements like the newer NC MX-5 ones are. Better 4th gear ratio too... To answer the OP question, if starting from scratch with a custom build... and I had a choice of S1 or S2 RX-8 trans, I'd select the S2. But if I could go with ANY Mazda production trans in the recent years, it'd be the NC MX-5 6spd (mounts on the drivers side PPF as well as the RX-8 so may be fairly easy to mount). Also, more support in the racing world for MX-5.. the weaknesses the MX-5 trans has have aftermarket fixes for already. I for one don't have many issues with my current S1 trans. It has been raced for the last 6 years pretty consistently and has over 90K miles on it. However, I've never been a gear slammer and take the right time between gear selections... also, I really believe the precision of the Exedy unsprung clutch system has helped tremendously with the RX8 trans. Is my trans perfect? No, but it's lasted WAY better then I thought it would... More trans research for next year as I'll probably pull the engine/trans for updates at that time...